Decision Fatigue

In partnership with

Welcome to Better You, the weekly newsletter that merges practical wisdom with tangible steps for entrepreneurs, solopreneurs, and professionals seeking to grow without losing themselves in the process. Today, we're exploring how to combat decision fatigue, that mental exhaustion that comes from making too many choices. By implementing strategic systems, you can preserve your mental energy for decisions that truly matter while automating or simplifying the rest.

The Turning Point

Alex had built his marketing consultancy from scratch, taking pride in personally reviewing every client proposal, approving every creative concept, and weighing in on every hiring decision. His attention to detail had helped establish his reputation for excellence. But lately, he noticed a troubling pattern: by mid-afternoon, his decision-making quality was declining sharply. Simple choices became overwhelming, and he found himself postponing important business decisions or making hasty judgments he later regretted.

The breaking point came when he lost a major client after delaying a critical proposal for the third time. When Alex analyzed what had happened, he realized he'd spent that morning deciding on office furniture, reviewing minor website changes, and handling client requests that his team could have managed. By the time he needed to finalize the important proposal, his mental reserves were depleted.

That weekend, Alex read about decision fatigue, the psychological principle that your decision-making quality deteriorates after making many sequential choices. He discovered that even mundane decisions drain the same mental reservoir needed for important ones. With this insight, Alex restructured his approach to decision-making. Within three months, he'd reclaimed hours of productive time, reduced his stress levels, and closed two of the largest deals in his company's history. Here are the five strategies that transformed his decision-making process.

There’s a reason 400,000 professionals read this daily.

Join The AI Report, trusted by 400,000+ professionals at Google, Microsoft, and OpenAI. Get daily insights, tools, and strategies to master practical AI skills that drive results.

Sign up now for free and work smarter, not harder.

Step 1: Identify Your High-Value Decisions

Not all decisions deserve equal mental energy. The first step to combating decision fatigue is distinguishing between decisions that significantly impact your business or life (high-value) and those with minimal long-term consequences (low-value).

Alex began by tracking every decision he made over three days, from what to wear to which client strategies to approve. He then categorized them by impact level: high (directly affected revenue, team culture, or long-term strategy), medium (moderate but not critical impact), or low (minimal consequence regardless of choice).

The results shocked him, nearly 70% of his decisions were low-value yet consumed about 55% of his decision-making time and energy. These included choosing lunch options, approving minor expense reports, and selecting which emails to answer first.

To implement this strategy yourself, keep a decision journal for at least three days. Note each decision you face, how long you spend on it, and its potential impact on your goals. Then ruthlessly identify which decisions truly deserve your limited mental bandwidth. Ask yourself: "Will this decision significantly impact my business six months from now?" If not, it may be a candidate for delegation, automation, or simplification.

Step 2: Create Decision-Making Systems and Frameworks

Once you've identified your high-value and low-value decisions, the next step is creating systems to handle routine choices efficiently.

Alex realized he wasted considerable energy on repetitive decisions like approving routine social media content and standard client reports. He developed simple frameworks for these recurring choices:

For social media approval, he created clear guidelines with examples of approved messaging, tone, and imagery. His team could now proceed independently when content checked all the boxes, only bringing exceptional cases to him.

For client reporting, he established a template with specific thresholds for flagging issues that needed his attention. Reports that fell within normal parameters were automatically approved.

You can apply this strategy by selecting one recurring decision that consumes your mental energy. Outline the key criteria you use when making a good decision in this category. Turn these criteria into a checklist or flowchart that you or your team can follow. Test your framework on the next ten decisions in this category, refining as needed.

For solo entrepreneurs without teams, creating decision rules for yourself works similarly. For instance, you might decide that client inquiries for projects below a certain budget receive a standardized proposal without custom elements, saving your creative energy for higher-value opportunities.

Step 3: Leverage Strategic Automation

Technology can eliminate countless small decisions that drain your mental reserves. The key is identifying decision points in your workflow that can be automated without sacrificing quality.

Alex examined where he repeatedly made similar choices and found several opportunities for automation:

He implemented an email filter system that automatically categorized incoming messages by urgency and type. Instead of deciding how to handle each of 100+ daily emails individually, he could process them in batches according to their category.

He set up a calendar system with pre-determined time blocks for different types of work, eliminating the daily decision of what to focus on next.

He created templates for common client communications, proposals, and internal briefs, which reduced the number of small writing and formatting decisions he made daily.

To apply this strategy, list processes in your work that involve numerous small decisions. Research tools that could automate these processes, whether through email filters, scheduling software, templates, or more advanced options like AI assistants for content creation.

Remember that automation isn't just digital, physical automation matters too. Steve Jobs famously wore the same outfit daily to eliminate clothing decisions. While you might not go that far, creating systems like meal planning or standardizing certain routines can free significant mental energy.

Step 4: Optimize Your Decision Environment and Timing

When and where you make decisions significantly impacts their quality. Research shows our decision-making abilities fluctuate throughout the day, with most people experiencing peak analytical capacity in the morning.

Alex restructured his schedule to protect his morning hours for high-value decisions. He blocked 9-11 AM for strategic thinking and important choices, postponing routine matters until afternoon. He also recognized that certain environments enhanced his decision clarity, particularly his quiet home office versus the busy main workspace.

His environmental adjustments included:

• Turning off notifications during decision-making blocks

• Creating a "decision zone" with minimal distractions

• Using noise-canceling headphones to maintain focus

• Keeping a notepad for capturing unrelated thoughts that emerged during important decisions, allowing him to return to them later rather than context-switching

To implement this strategy, identify your personal decision-making prime time by tracking your energy and clarity throughout the day for one week. Schedule your most important decisions during these peak periods. Then, design your decision environment, eliminate distractions, ensure comfort, and prepare any information you'll need in advance so the decision process flows smoothly.

The simple act of deciding when and where you'll make important decisions eliminates meta-decisions and preserves mental energy for the choice itself.

Step 5: Practice Intentional Decision Simplification

The final strategy involves deliberately reducing the complexity of decisions whenever possible.

Alex had fallen into a common entrepreneurial trap, treating every decision as an opportunity for optimization. He would consider countless variables for even moderately important choices, seeking the "perfect" option rather than a good one.

He began practicing intentional simplification through several techniques:

Setting decision time limits proportional to importance. Major client strategy decisions might get 30 focused minutes, while selecting a vendor for office supplies would get no more than 5 minutes.

Reducing options deliberately. When hiring, he went from reviewing all applicants to only seeing the top five candidates pre-screened by his HR consultant.

Accepting "good enough" for low and medium-impact decisions. For these categories, he adopted the "70% rule", if an option seemed about 70% as good as the theoretically perfect choice, he would take it and move on.

You can apply this strategy by first identifying areas where you tend to over-complicate decisions. For your next decision in these areas, try pre-committing to a simplified approach: limit your research time, reduce the number of options you'll consider, or set clear-enough criteria that, once met, trigger an immediate decision.

Remember that simplification isn't laziness, it's strategic conservation of your most precious resource: your mental energy. By simplifying low-impact decisions, you preserve capacity for the truly consequential choices that define your business success.

Pulling It All Together

Decision fatigue silently erodes the quality of our choices and drains our mental resources. By identifying your high-value decisions, creating frameworks for routine choices, leveraging automation, optimizing your decision environment, and practicing intentional simplification, you can make better decisions while preserving your mental energy for what truly matters.

The most successful entrepreneurs aren't necessarily those who make perfect decisions, they're those who create systems that allow them to make consistently good decisions for the long haul. They recognize that decision-making capacity is a finite resource that must be managed as carefully as time or money.

Alex's story reminds us that sometimes the most important business improvement isn't a new marketing strategy or product innovation, it's upgrading how we handle the hundreds of decisions that shape our daily work and ultimate success.

This week, choose just one decision type that repeatedly drains your energy, and apply one of these strategies to it. Notice how freeing it feels to remove even a single source of decision fatigue from your life. Then gradually expand your system to embrace more of your decision landscape. Your future self, with more mental clarity, faster execution, and reduced stress, will thank you.

Until next week.